8 min read

The 5 Best Roofing Companies in Fayetteville, NC for 2024

The 5 Best Roofing Companies in Fayetteville, NC for 2024
How do you find the best roofers? Ask an experienced roofing contractor who knows all the other roofing contractors in Fayetteville NC!

Roof repairs gone wrong? Not cool. You could end up with leaks, serious damage, or even mold.

And roof replacements... that's a whole new level of complexity. You're trusting a roofing contractor to take off your home's protective covering and put it all back together without a hitch.

But here's the thing, if you pick an unreliable or inexperienced roofer, you're opening yourself up to a whole bunch of unnecessary problems. Trust me, it's a situation you definitely want to avoid.

In this article, I'm going to reveal the best roofing contractors in the Fayetteville area. I will then go over pricing for a new roof and roof repairs, then give you some questions to ask. 

Let's get started!


Fayetteville Roofing Company

Why Should you Trust This List?

So you might be wondering why a roofing company serving the Fayetteville area would openly talk about their competition, right?

Well, let me tell you a little about the On Tops' story.

At On Tops Roofing, our mission is simple - we want to be the ultimate source of roofing information for homeowners in North Carolina.

On Tops is a veteran-owned family business that has been serving Fayetteville and the surrounding area for over 30 years. My team has installed thousands of roofs and completed countless repairs. And in the process, we've seen it all - the good, the bad, and just about everything in between.

That said, I understand we might not be the perfect fit for everyone.

Trust me, there are some true professionals out there. But along with the few good roofers in Fayetteville, unfortunately, there are some not-so-great options too. I want to make sure you stay away from those!

That's why I'm open to discussing my opinions on other roofing contractors in the Fayetteville area. Whether you choose On Tops Roofing or not, we want to share our knowledge so we can empower you with valuable insights and make sure you have a positive roofing experience.

Alrighty then, now that I've got all the important details covered, let's get this show on the road and help you find the best roofing company in Fayetteville NC!


The Top Roofing Companies in Fayetteville, NC

  1. Blue Ribbon Roofing
  2. Southern Premier Roofing
  3. Calvary Roofing
  4. The Roof Mentors
  5. Advanced Roofing Solutions

Blue Ribbon Roofing

Blue Ribbon Roofing is a locally owned company serving Fayetteville and the surrounding communities. They perform residential and commercial roof replacement services as well as roof leak repair. The business was founded in 2017 by Lewis Hardin, a roofing expert with 25 years of experience. Lewis and his company have done a good job of staying on top of all the latest trends. Blue Ribbon Roofing is an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor.

Blue Ribbon Roofing



Southern Premier Roofing

Southern Premier Roofing offers a wide range of services including roof replacement, roof repair, and gutter installation. They were founded in Raleigh in 2019 by Kent Graham. Southern Premier Roofing can handle storm-damaged roofs as well as gutters, siding, and exterior/interior painting. They primarily install GAF products.

Southern Premier Roofing - Logo



Calvary Roofing

Calvary Roofing is one of the roofing contractors based in Fayetteville, NC. They were founded in 2019 and offer roof repair services and roof replacements. Calvary specializes in the installation of Atlas shingles. The business is headed by Kevin Callaway, an army veteran. As a locally owned business, they take pride in serving the Fayetteville community for roofing services.

Calvary Roofing - Logo



The Roof Mentors

The Roof Mentors in Fayetteville, NC, offers new roof installation, roof replacement, roof inspections, storm-damaged roof repairs, and commercial roofing. Roof Mentors was founded in 2019 by partners Tyler McGowan and Nolan Clark who moved to North Carolina from Georgia. Since their founding, they have opened locations in Fayetteville, Hope Mills, Raeford, Dunn, and Winston-Salem.

The Roof Mentors - Logo



Advanced Roofing Solutions

Advanced Roofing Solutions, founded in 2017 by Joseph Tonet, serves the greater Fayetteville area. They perform a wide range of roofing services from new roof installations to residential roof repair and storm damage repairs. Advanced Roofing Solutions also offers installations of metal roofing and commercial roofing.

Advanced Roofing Solutions - Logo



How Much Does a New Roof Cost?

As you may have guessed, determining the cost of any home project, including the repair or replacement of your roof isn't a straightforward, one-size-fits-all situation. It relies on various factors, such as the size and complexity of your roof and the specific materials you use.

That said, I will do my best to answer the question. The On Tops team tracks the projects we've done from over 30 years of roofing in North Carolina and the "average" cost for roof installation is approximately $15,700. The majority of roofs we've performed fell within the price range of $12,400 to $18,200. 

When budgeting to have a roof replaced in Fayetteville NC, it's advisable to anticipate a cost of at least $40 per square foot. This estimate accounts for the architectural asphalt shingles chosen by most homeowners and covers expenses related to labor, materials, minor damage repairs, and warranties.

Opting for premium shingles or metal roofing can also increase the overall cost. Metal roofs tend to be a bit pricier, averaging around $50 per square foot. Other factors, such as the complexity of the roof design and the need for extensive repairs or modifications, can further impact the final price.


How Much Does it Cost to Repair Your Roof?

The cost of roof repairs can vary depending on several factors, such as the extent of the damage and the specific type of repair required.

For minor repairs, such as fixing a few damaged shingles, replacing a couple missing shingles, or addressing a small leak, you can expect to spend anywhere from a few hundred dollars to about $1,500. These types of repairs are relatively straightforward and can be completed relatively quickly by a professional roofing contractor.

Major repairs, such as fixing extensive damage or addressing structural issues are more complex and time-consuming. This results in higher costs that can run into the thousands of dollars.

It's super important to tackle these issues ASAP to prevent any more damage to your roof and potential leaks or structural problems in your home. Periodic maintenance and roof inspections can also help catch damages early on before they turn into bigger headaches.

While cost is an important consideration, it shouldn't be the sole factor in choosing a roofing company. Be cautious of quotes that appear too good to be true. They often come with hidden charges or subpar workmanship. Investing in quality work upfront will save you money. It will keep you from future repair expenses or the need for a premature roof replacement.

In addition to repair costs, it's essential to consider any additional work that may be necessary. This can include replacing damaged gutters, installing new roof decking, or repairing fascia boards. These additional tasks can contribute to the overall cost of the roof repair project but are important for ensuring the long-term durability and functionality of your roof.

When obtaining a quote from a roofing company, request a detailed breakdown of all costs involved. This should include labor charges, the type and cost of roofing materials, and any additional services or materials required for the repairs.


Ready to Hire a Fayetteville Roofing Company?

Your roof plays a crucial role in protecting your home. When evaluating the best roofing contractors in Fayetteville, it's essential to listen to your instincts. If something feels off, it's best to investigate further.

Whether you reside in Fayetteville, Hope Mills, Spring Lake, Raeford, or anywhere in between, our goal is to provide you with valuable information and resources to aid you in your search for a trusted roofing company.

If you still feel the need for more information before making a final decision, we recommend exploring our blog post on the key considerations for finding a great local roofing company. This resource offers valuable insights and guidance to assist you in your search and can help ensure that you find the perfect roofing company for your needs.

And please do consider On Tops Roofing. Since 1991 we've been committed to delivering exceptional service and quality work to our customers.

We're a veteran-owned family business and would be honored to be one of the companies you choose to evaluate. No matter what roofing services you need, we've got you covered! (pun intended) Happy roofing!


Questions to Ask a Roofing Company

Before you lock in on a roofing company, it's super important to gather all the details about their services and expertise. Here are some key questions you might want to ask.
How long have you been in business?

When it comes to the roofing business, experience is crucial. Ensure that the company you choose has a solid track record and extensive experience.

I've seen numerous roofing companies come and go over the years. It's important to consider the long-term reliability of the contractor you choose. What good is an extended warranty if the roofing contractor is no longer in business to honor it?

By selecting a reputable and established roofing company, you'll have peace of mind knowing they will be there to stand behind their work and honor any warranties or guarantees.

What type of insurance do you have?

A reputable roofing company should have both liability and workers' compensation insurance to protect themselves, their employees, and your property.

Liability insurance provides coverage in case of accidents or damage caused by the roofing company's work, ensuring that you're not held liable for any unforeseen incidents. It includes protection against property damage, personal injury claims, and legal expenses.

Workers' compensation insurance safeguards the employees of the roofing company in case of injuries or accidents that may occur while working on your property. It covers medical expenses, lost wages, and rehabilitation costs for the injured workers.

By having comprehensive liability and workers' compensation insurance, the roofing company takes responsibility for any potential risks and provides a layer of protection for both themselves and their clients. This commitment to safety and accountability is an important factor to consider when choosing a roofing company for your project.

Do you hold a General Contractors License?

When searching for roofing contractors in Fayetteville NC, it is highly advisable to ask whether they hold a general contractors license.  Believe it or not, for jobs less than $30,000, a general contractors license isn't needed in the state of North Carolina. Crazy right? Some in the roofing industry argue a license isn't necessary, but I firmly believe it's crucial. A licensed contractor not only demonstrates their commitment to professionalism and expertise but it's one of the indicators that they can deliver quality workmanship. Your roof is a substantial investment that you expect to last for twenty years or more. Its only logical to entrust the job to a contractor who possesses the necessary knowledge and skills. I certainly wouldn't cut corners when it comes to my roof... it's one of the most critical components of your home. 

What warranties do you provide?

When choosing a roofing company, it's important to select one that not only delivers exceptional work but also stands behind it. A reputable roofing company will offer two types of warranties: manufacturer warranties and workmanship warranties.

Manufacturer warranties cover defects or issues with the roofing materials, such as product failure or premature deterioration. These warranties are typically for a set period and vary depending on the manufacturer and type of material used.

Workmanship warranties, on the other hand, protect against any problems arising from errors in installation or workmanship. These types of warranties are usually provided by the roofing company itself and can range from a few years to a "lifetime". Ask to see the actual paperwork and don't just take their word for it. It's important to understand what is covered under these warranties and for how long so that you can make an informed decision. 

What shingles and other products will you use and why?

A reputable roofing company should possess extensive knowledge about the various types of shingles and accessories available in the market. With their expertise, they can provide valuable recommendations on the best options tailored to your specific roofing needs.

Here's something you should know... to qualify for manufacturer's warranties, the roofing contractor must install a complete roofing system that meets the manufacturer's requirements. For instance, GAF mandates the installation of a minimum of four of their "Qualifying Accessory Products," such as Starter Strip Shingles, Ridge Cap Shingles, underlayment, attic vents, or weather watch leak barrier. The best roofing companies will adhere to these specifications to protect the manufacturer's warranty. It's also important to ensure the longevity and effectiveness of your roofing system.

Will homeowners insurance cover the cost of my roof?

This is a common question that many homeowners have when facing roofing repairs or replacements, especially after hail damage. The answer largely depends on your specific insurance company, your policy, and the cause of the damage to your roof.

In most cases, homeowner's insurance will cover the cost if the damage was caused by a sudden event such as a hailstorm, storm, fire, or vandalism. However, if the damage is due to wear and tear or lack of maintenance, it may not be covered. It's important to thoroughly review your insurance policy and discuss any potential coverage with your roofing company beforehand.

Don't be pressured into unnecessary repairs or replacements and always get a second opinion if you're unsure. A reputable roofing company will work with you and your insurance company to find the best solution for your needs.

The 5 Best Roofing Companies in Fayetteville, NC for 2024

The 5 Best Roofing Companies in Fayetteville, NC for 2024

How do you find the best roofers? Ask an experienced roofing contractor who knows all the other roofing contractors in Fayetteville NC!

Read More
Benefits of a Project Manager for Your Roof Replacement

Benefits of a Project Manager for Your Roof Replacement

A roof replacement is a substantial undertaking, and the key to a successful project often lies in the hands of the project manager. This individual...

Read More
Signs Your Roof Has Storm Damage

Signs Your Roof Has Storm Damage

If you’ve recently experienced a storm, you should probably take some time to investigate your roof for signs of damage left by that storm.

Read More